Anyone with a kid on a track team knows the math: the athletes train for weeks for a race that’s over in a couple of minutes, the same way a performer rehearses a stunt for years in order to land it in a few seconds under the lights. We parents get relegated to the bleachers for hours, which leaves plenty of time for conversation, and most of it sounds like a scouting report. What’s your kid’s race? The 1K. Yours? The 400. What school? It volleys along politely until someone more familiar walks over, and the conversation drifts off with them.
We reach for those questions for a good reason. Where do you work, where did you go to school, do you know so-and-so, where are you from? They look for common ground through proximity, and they often work. Plenty of careers, mine included, have been built on a mutual friend vouching for a stranger. The catch is that the trust is borrowed from someone who isn’t sitting with you. Two parents on the same bench at 6 p.m. on a Wednesday already share something, and it’s happening right in front of them.
This Wednesday put that to the test. A parent I knew was sitting with a few others, so admittedly the night started with a little borrowed trust. A quick hello to the group, a mention of which runner was our daughter, and then a pause, with no question attached.
The mom next to me filled it. Her daughter has been on the team for a few years, and her stories answered questions before they were asked and raised a few new ones. Soon the whole row was talking about how sports shaped us and what it’s like to watch our kids compete. Her daughter heads to college next year, and when her husband joined a little later, the two of them were open about how they’re feeling and what comes next. They’ve taken up birding, which feels fitting for two soon-to-be empty nesters. One question about what they’d spotted in Central Park lately, and the conversation went straight to birds of prey. Nobody asked anyone what they did for a living, and I’ll never see those two again without thinking of birds.
Asking near-strangers how they feel about their kid leaving home could have gone sideways. Behavioral scientists who paired more than 1,800 strangers, from grad students to financial executives, for either small talk or a real conversation found that fear is mostly misplaced. People expected the deeper conversations to be awkward and walked away from them feeling more connected than they did after the small talk.
My best friend had notes when she heard about my night at the track meet, which is exactly what best friends are for. She’s a curious, intriguing, and dynamic conversationalist in her own right. She pointed out that my favorite move, the creative question that makes people think, can be off-putting. For some people it lands as a pop quiz, her mother, for one. Ask her mother what her spirit animal might be and she would rather you didn’t. Give her a chance to turn to the person beside her and offer a word of praise or a wish, and she’s all in. The willingness is there, but how the invitation is offered decides whether people take it.
Noticing is a skill I learned long ago through years of negotiations and show production: walk into a room and take in everything before saying a word. At a track meet, it might sound like, “This is a big stage for a bunch of teenagers, and their athleticism and courage are worth every hour on these bleachers.” Then let it sit. At a cocktail party, next to someone like my friend’s mother, it might be, “What a striking brooch. Is there a story behind it?” Neither line asks the other person to perform, and both give them somewhere to go.
If you want to try it, start with what you can both see, whether that’s the room, the reason you’re there, or something the other person chose to wear or carry. Try a statement and a pause before reaching for a question. Oftentimes, a little quiet invites more than a question does. When someone hands you something real, like a kid leaving for college, follow it with care. Pay attention to who you’re talking to, since some people light up at a thought-provoking prompt and others would rather be handed something easy to say yes to.
The night started with which runner was ours and ended with birds of prey and two people who had been strangers an hour earlier. The best opener of the evening was a pause, and a mom I’d just met was generous enough to fill it.
From Your Biggest Champion,
Nicole